如何精读一篇论文，思路是什么？ && how to write a good research paper?
一篇论文应该读懂什么?
inspired by post Doc. feng
- 模型以及推倒：最难啃的，要读懂文章提出的model and computing equation
- 创新点：去理解论文的发展脉络
- 文章从哪个模型改进来的，改进的那些？
- 为什么要这么设计model？好处是什么？
- model解决了什么问题？
- 实验结果：以自己的角度去理解文章提出的模型到底好不好？
- 那些地方好？是否实验结果很优秀？
- 是否架构简单？
- 改进：文章改进点在哪里？
How to write a great research paper
stucture of an paper
- abstract (4 sentences )
- introduction (1 page )
- the problem(1 page )
- my idea (2 pages )
- the details (5 pages)
- related work (1-2 pages)
- conclusions and further work (pages)
Don’t wait ,write.your idea ->write a paper ->do research
- don’t wait if you have a good idea ,write it
- writing is a tool to communicate with yourself
identify your key idea ,identify
- we all feel that our idea is weedy and insignificant ,just write a paper about your weedy and insignificant idea anyway .Don’t wait till you have a good idea to write something ,write any idea and don’t be intimidated
- you may not be very clear at the beginning ,but you must be clear of what your idea is when you finished your paper .
- just one ‘ping’-one paper should just have one idea ,if you have lots of ideas ,just write lots of papers
- Key thought many papers contains good ideas,but do not distill what they are ,you must make certain that the reader is in no doubt what the idea is .and just be 100% explicit
- the main idea of this paper is ……
- in this section we present the main contributions of the paper
tell a story
- here is a problem
- it’s an interesting problem
- it’s unsolved
- Here is my idea
- my idea works (how ? experiment ? data? details? )
- here is my works compares to other people’s approaches
nail your contributions to the mast
- how to write introduction
- describe the problem (the speaker always introduce problems with an examle )
- molehills not mountainside ,explain your problem explict and interesting but complex and empty
- state your contributions
- write the list of contributions first
- the list of contributions drives the entire paper :the paper substantiates the claims you have made
- this will attract readers to read more
- that’s all in one page
- describe the problem (the speaker always introduce problems with an examle )
- how to write introduction
related work:
- Later , it should’t be at the beginning of the paper ,because the reader can still not understand what the problems and your idea is. after you have explicitly explained your work ,you can start to intruduce it.
- give credit to other works, share your love ,you get more love. so ,be warm to acknowledge people who have helped you .
- acknowledge weakness in your approach
put your readers first
- use examples rather than theorems to make the explanation more live
listen to your readers
- listen to your reviewer , be grateful for criticism as well as praise .it’s hard but important
- listen to an expert ,let the expert examine your work and your statement
- Guinea pigs is helpful , make the problem X is apparent even for the stupidest reader